Entertainment
Prince Harry and six other claimants ordered to pay initial £9.5 million after failed Daily Mail privacy lawsuit
A London High Court judge ruled the claimants exhibited unreasonable conduct and declined to cap legal costs, leaving them exposed to millions more in liabilities.
The short version
- A London High Court judge ordered Prince Harry, Sir Elton John, and five other high-profile claimants to pay an interim £9.54 million to Daily Mail publisher Associated Newspapers Ltd. by August 28.
- The ruling follows the July dismissal of all 97 privacy invasion and unlawful information-gathering claims brought against the publisher.
- The judge declined to cap the publisher's recoverable expenses despite calling the £34.5 million defense bill seemingly excessive, leaving the claimants exposed to roughly £18 million beyond their £16.2 million insurance coverage.
- The claimants have until October 2 to decide whether to appeal the decision, while remaining costs are expected to undergo detailed assessment.
Key facts
- Justice Matthew Nicklin ordered Prince Harry, Sir Elton John, David Furnish, Baroness Doreen Lawrence, Sadie Frost, Liz Hurley, and Sir Simon Hughes to make an interim payment of £9.54 million (roughly $13 million) to Associated Newspapers Ltd. by August 28.[BBC News · PBS NewsHour]
- Justice Nicklin ruled costs will be assessed on an indemnity basis, criticizing the claimants' conduct as 'unreasonable to a high degree' for failing to withdraw serious allegations when evidential support was lacking.[BBC News · PBS NewsHour]
- Associated Newspapers claimed defense costs of up to £34.5 million, exceeding an initial £16 million budget estimate.[BBC News · ABC News]
- The claimants held insurance covering approximately £16.2 million, leaving them potentially liable for up to £18 million more if the full defense costs are approved.[BBC News · PBS NewsHour]
- The High Court dismissed all 97 claims of unlawful information gathering on July 7 following an 11-week trial, citing insufficient evidence.[BBC News · ABC News · PBS NewsHour]
What remains uncertain
- The final amount the claimants will ultimately pay remains unsettled, as specialized costs judges may further assess whether the publisher's total bill was reasonably incurred.[BBC News · PBS NewsHour]
- It is not yet known whether the claimants will appeal either the substantive ruling or the costs judgment before the October 2 deadline.[BBC News · PBS NewsHour]
Sources
- Prince Harry and 6 others must pay initial $13 million over failed invasion of privacy casePBS NewsHour - World
- Prince Harry and six others face privacy case legal bill of up to £34.5mBBC News - Entertainment & Arts
- Prince Harry and 6 others to learn initial cost of failed Daily Mail caseABC News - Entertainment